top of page

Help Us Solve A Cold Case: Molly Dattilo is Still Missing

Nov 11
5 min read

Updated: 5 days ago

Person walking a dark forest path with a flashlight, illustrating entrepreneur lessons in grit and hope from the Molly Dattilo case

When police told Molly Dattilo’s family to wait, they refused. What they did over the next 22 years changed Indiana law and changed how I think about everything.


This is a personal plea from me, Julie Lokun. Please keep this story alive and let's solve this case together. Molly is the cousin of a dear friend in Indianapolis- and it is so important to keep this story fresh. Please share with everyone you know. --With Gratitude, Julie


I want to say this up front: Molly Dattilo is not a business case study. She was a 22-year-old college student, a runner and a singer, the youngest of nine kids. She has been missing since July 6, 2004, and her family has spent more than two decades trying to bring her home.


I've written about Molly before because her cousin, Keri Dattilo, was my best friend in college. I watched Keri and the rest of the Dattilo family take on a job nobody ever applies for. And the longer I work with entrepreneurs, the more I notice something uncomfortable. What that family did in the worst season of their lives looks a lot like what the best founders do on their best days. They saw a broken system. They refused to accept the answer they were given. Then they built something that outlasted the moment.


If you're building something right now and it feels like nobody is listening, their story is worth your time. If it moves you, there's a way to help at the end.


What happened to Molly


On the day she disappeared, Molly went to class, did some shopping, and walked to a Wendy's near her brother's Indianapolis apartment around 7 p.m. to drop off a job application. A friend of her brother's ran into her on the way and remembered she had her cell phone with her.


Later that night she went to a party at the Westlake Apartments complex, where she met a man named John E. Shelton. The two left together, took a rowboat out on the complex's retention pond, and ate at a nearby Taco Bell. Around 11 p.m., they were at a Thorntons gas station in Speedway, a few miles away and in the opposite direction of the apartments. Molly tried to call a friend from the pay phone. The line went dead as soon as the friend picked up.


No one other than Shelton reported seeing her after that. He said he took her home.


Her brother reported her missing on July 8. Because Molly was an adult, police initially treated it as if she had left on her own. Her car, phone, bank card, money and ID were all still at the apartment. Her family has said it took about six weeks before an active investigation really got underway.


When the gatekeepers won't answer, go around them


A lone gate in an open field with no fence, showing how entrepreneurs can go around gatekeepers

Those first weeks are the part of the story I can't shake. The people with the authority to act told the family to wait, and the most valuable days in the case slipped by.


So the Dattilos stopped waiting. They launched their own media campaign, pushed Molly's story to local news outlets, and collected every lead they could find.


Every entrepreneur hits a version of this, though with far lower stakes. The investor who won't take the meeting. The reporter who never replies. The big client who keeps saying "circle back next quarter." Waiting on a gatekeeper can feel responsible, and sometimes it is. But waiting is also a decision, and it costs time you don't get back.


The Dattilos went straight to the public. In business terms, that means building your own audience, your own channels, and your own relationships so a single "no" can't stall everything you're working on.


Fix the system, not only your own problem


Here is what still amazes me. While they were searching for Molly, her family also advocated for a change in the law. The Molly Dattilo Law, enacted in 2007 and updated in 2013, directs Indiana law enforcement to take missing-person reports for adults and to start investigating immediately when the person is considered high risk.


That law didn't bring Molly home. It does mean that another family, on another terrible night, won't be told to wait the way the Dattilos were.


I think about this whenever a client tells me about a business idea born from frustration. Many of the strongest companies start exactly there, with someone who hit a wall, realized other people were hitting the same wall, and decided to tear it down for everyone. If something in your industry is broken and it hurts you, there's a good chance it's hurting your future customers too.


Decide what winning looks like when the ideal outcome is off the table


A chess pawn standing over a fallen king, showing how entrepreneurs can redefine winning when the ideal outcome is out of reach

No one has ever been criminally charged in Molly's case. Police have said they never had enough evidence to file charges.


The family worked with an attorney instead and filed a civil lawsuit against John E. Shelton and his father, Edward Shelton, the two men they believe were involved. In 2010, they won a judgment of nearly $3.5 million. They have said they don't expect to ever collect a dollar. What they got was a public, legal record of what they believed, and a measure of justice when full justice wasn't available. In 2017, after petitions from Molly's mother and siblings, a judge declared her legally dead.


As a lawyer, I respect that strategy enormously. As someone who coaches people through big transitions, I see it all the time in smaller forms. The acquisition falls through. The launch flops. The partner walks. The outcome you planned for disappears, and you have to decide what the next real win is.


That isn't the same as giving up. The Dattilos never stopped pushing for a criminal case or for the chance to find Molly and lay her to rest. They simply refused to let the perfect outcome be the only one they would accept.


Keep saying her name


It has been 22 years. The family is still talking. Friends are still sharing. In January 2025, the FBI's Violent Criminal Apprehension Program put out a fresh alert on Molly's case to law enforcement agencies, which tells me the attention is still doing its work.


I think this is the lesson most founders underestimate. People need to hear your story many, many times before it sticks. Most of us stop telling it long before our audience has actually heard it. The Dattilo family shows what consistency looks like when it really matters: you keep showing up and telling the story, year after year, because the story is what keeps the door open.


How you can help


One person passing a candle’s light to another, a call to share Molly Dattilo’s story and help bring her home

You don't need to be a detective. You need to keep Molly's name in circulation.


Anyone with information about Molly Dattilo's disappearance or the location of her remains can contact Crime Stoppers of Central Indiana at 317-262-TIPS (8477) or the Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department at 317-327-6160.


Share her story. Use #FindMolly. You can find more details about the case on The Charley Project.



Cre8tive Con is hitting the road! Join us January 14, 2027, at The Secret Office Studio in Orlando, Florida, for a day of fresh ideas, hands-on learning, and meaningful connections. Whether you're an entrepreneur, author, podcaster, or content creator, you'll have the chance to meet fellow creatives, learn from experienced strategists, and take your next big step.


Cre8tive Con On The Road Orlando flyer for a one-day entrepreneur and podcaster event at The Secret Office Studio on January 14, 2027


 
 
 

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
© 2026 Cre8tive Con/ dba The Mediacasters LLC
JOIN US IN 2027!
Follow Us On Instagram:
Join Our Facebook Community: 
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
3.png
bottom of page